… and the essential difference between moderate and vigorous workouts.
- Current guidelines recommend 150-300 minutes/week of moderate physical activity (MPA) or 75-150 min/wk of vigorous physical activity (VPA).
- A 30-year study suggests that doubling current guidelines to 300-600 min/wk of MPA or 150-300 min/wk of VPA lowers all-cause mortality.
- Doing 2-4 times the recommended “dose” of weekly exercise doesn’t cause harm, but all-cause mortality benefits stop after 600 min/wk.
The currentphysical activity guidelines recommend a minimum of 150-300 minutes per week (min/wk) of moderate physical activity (MPA), 75-150 min/wk of vigorous physical activity (VPA), or an equivalent combination of MPA and VPA. The current guidelines (Piercy et al., 2018) also recommend doing full-body strength-training workouts twice a week.
A recent analysis of data from 116,221 adults who participated in two longitudinal studies conducted over 30 years (1988–2018) found that people who performed double—or up to four times—the minimum recommended dose of moderate or vigorous physical activity lived longer.
This analysis (Lee et al., 2022) suggests that 300-600 min/wk of moderate physical activity or 150-300 min/wk of vigorous exercise significantly reduces all-cause mortality risk. On July 25 in the American Heart Association’s peer-reviewed journalCirculation published these findings.
“The nearly maximum association with lower mortality was achieved by performing ≈150 to 300 min/wk of long-term leisure-time VPA, 300 to 600 min/wk of long-term leisure-time MPA, or an equivalent combination of both,” the authors explain.
The Dividing Line Between Moderate and Vigorous Exercise
For this analysis, first author Donghoon Lee of Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public Health and colleagues define vigorous exercise as any activity that uses more than six METs of energy.
A Metabolic Equivalent Task (MET) unit gauges the amount of energy required to perform different tasks or physical activities at varying intensities. For example, sitting in a chair uses one MET, walking at three miles per hour (mph) uses about four METs, and slow jogging uses about six METs. (Click here for a complete list of how many METs to use during different physical activities at varying intensities.)
Sitting uses about one MET of energy. Commuter biking uses about 5 METs, whereas climbing stairs or jogging slowly uses about 6 METs. Running fast uses 8-10 METs.
The cardiorespiratory transition from walking to jogging is a perfect example of how moderate-intensity physical activity morphs into vigorous aerobic exercise as indexed by METs. For example, walking slower than 3.5 mph typically uses fewer than six METs. However, if you walk at a brisk pace that’s faster than 3.5 mph or break into a jog as your speed increases to 4 mph or more, you’ll cross the threshold from moderate to vigorous cardio and start using ≥6 METs.
150-600 Minutes of Weekly Physical Activity Lowers All-Cause Mortality
Following are some stats from the latest (2022) analysis by Lee et al.:
- Participants who followed current guidelines and did150-300 min/wkof moderate physical activity (MPA) had a20 to 21 percentlower risk of death from all causes.
- Participants who followed current guidelines and did75-150 min/wkof vigorous physical activity (VPA) had a19 percentlower risk of death from all causes.
- Participants who performed300-600 min/wkof MPA (two to four times above current guidelines) had a26 to 31 percentlower risk of mortality from all causes.
- Participants who performed150-300 min/wkof VPA (two to four times above current guidelines) had a21 to 23 percentlower risk of death from all causes.
600 Minutes of Weekly Cardio Isn’t Harmful, But Benefits Stop After 10 hrs/wk
Previous studies have suggested that, over time, high-intensity endurance training and competition—such as running marathons, competing in Ironman triathlons (2.4-mile swim, 112-mile bike, 26.2-mile run), or doing ultra-endurance bicycle races—may increase someone’s risk of adverse cardiovascular events.
However, the latest peer-reviewed analysis (2022) found that doing two to four times more than the recommended weekly exercise guidelines doesn’t increase someone’s risk of atrial fibrillation, coronary artery calcification, myocardial fibrosis, or sudden cardiac death.
“This finding may reduce the concerns around the potentially harmful effect of engaging in high levels of physical activity observed in several previous studies,” Lee said in a July 2022news release.
Notably, engaging in more than 300 minutes/week (5 hours) of vigorous physical activity or more than 600 minutes/week (10 hours) of moderate-intensity physical activity doesn’t appear to provide a bigger reduction in all-cause mortality death risk.
“No harmful cardiovascular health effects were found among the adults who reported engaging in more than four times the recommended minimum activity levels,” the authors note. But, they add a caveat: “However, among those who reported ≥300 min/wk of long-term leisure-time MPA, additional leisure-time VPA did not appear to be associated with lower mortality beyond MPA.”
article continues after advertisement
Current Exercise Guidelines Are in the Right Ballpark, But Doing More Weekly Activity May Provide Extra Life-Extending Benefits
“Our study provides evidence to guide individuals to choose the right amount and intensity of physical activity over their lifetime to maintain their overall health,” Lee concludes. “Our findings support the current national physical activity guidelines and further suggest that the maximum benefits may be achieved by performing medium to high levels of either moderate or vigorous activity or a combination.”