They’re calling her a dead woman walking.

After the dramatic jailbreak, Sheriff Susan Hutson was dragged across the media landscape. The public saw failure, and many declared her political career finished. Even I had sharp words. In my own piece—“Jailbreak, Blame, and a Shocking Leadership Failure”—I didn’t hold back.

But one thing is clear: while her campaign took a brutal hit, it’s not over. In fact, this sheriff’s race is still a race.

The Jailbreak Fallout

Hutson’s response to the jailbreak was flawed—no question. It exposed glaring problems in communication, staffing, and oversight. But that one moment should not erase the broader context.

The truth is, the Orleans Parish jail has been broken for decades. Hutson inherited a deeply flawed system—underfunded, poorly designed, and politically isolated. The jailbreak just made it visible.

Funding Fights and Finger Pointing

New Orleans once locked up more than 7,000 people, many for minor infractions like traffic tickets and marijuana. The massive jail fed on mass incarceration, devastating families and destabilizing neighborhoods.

A University of Michigan study confirmed that pretrial jail time causes job loss, housing insecurity, and long-term trauma. Think504.com has also documented how jailing poor people over fines and fees weakened Black communities.

That’s the system Hutson was elected to reform.

Susan Hutson’s Reform Legacy

Hutson defeated a New Orleans political powerhouse, Marlin Gusman, a politicians who had never lost an election. Her message was clear—fewer inmates, smarter justice, more dignity.

She cut fees for phone calls to keep families connected. That humane change also slashed one of the jail’s key revenue streams. In other words, her values hit her bottom line.

On top of that, City Council members JP Morrell and Helena Moreno have consistently underfunded her office. They’ve rejected budget increases and challenged her authority. Hutson has said repeatedly that the jail building is defective, demanding more maintenance than her budget can handle.

Who’s Really to Blame?

Critics have focused on Hutson disbanding the high-security tier for the most dangerous inmates. She says it was due to budget constraints. Many voters aren’t buying that explanation. That misstep lingers.

But she’s not the only problem here.

She runs a jail under federal oversight. The building is flawed. Her budget is thin. And the political will to fix those things simply doesn’t exist. This campaign is becoming a referendum—not just on Hutson—but on whether the city wants to spend what it takes to run a jail safely and humanely.

A Race With No Clear Favorite

None of her opponents have experience running a jail, let alone one as complicated as Orleans Parish. They’re attacking her record—but not offering real solutions. It’s easy to critique. It’s hard to govern.

Hutson, on the other hand, knows the deficiencies of the building, understands the consent decree, and has a plan—flawed or not. She’s a lawyer, a polished communicator, and a strong campaigner.

She still has name recognition. She still has a loyal base. And she still has time.

Do New Orleanians Want a New Jail Strategy?

This election is no longer just about Susan Hutson.

It’s about the future of incarceration in New Orleans.

• Will the city invest in better jail infrastructure?
• Will voters demand real reform—or just a new face?
• Will anyone running for sheriff get the funding they need?

Right now, Hutson’s campaign is wounded. But if voters look deeper—past the headlines and into the policy—they’ll see that she’s far from finished.

In fact, the rumors of her political death have been greatly exaggerated.